Hiring the Right Customer Service Director: What Great Looks Like

When customer service starts to creak, complaints rise, or your team feels like it’s always firefighting - the answer isn’t another process or platform. 

It’s leadership. 

The right Customer Service Director won’t just steady the ship. They’ll redesign it for scale, clarity, and value. But hiring that person - and knowing what great looks like - isn’t always straightforward. 

Here’s what to look for if you want more than a “safe pair of hands.” 

1. They Think Like an Operator, Not Just a Leader 

A great CS Director isn’t afraid to get into the weeds when needed - but they also think at system level. 
Look for someone who can: 

• Design scalable operating models 
• Understand cost-to-serve, demand drivers, and SLAs
• Drive clarity across people, process, and platforms
• Spot inefficiencies and fix root causes - fast 

They should speak the language of both frontline teams and the boardroom. 

2. They Know the Customer, Not Just the Metrics 

Great CS leaders don’t just quote CSAT and NPS -they feel what’s behind them. 

• They spend time listening to calls. 
•  Reading complaints. 
• Understanding journeys. 
• Asking, “Why are customers contacting us in the first place?” 

Look for someone obsessed with outcomes, not just reporting. 

3. They Bring Calm in Chaos 

The best CS Directors walk into high-volume, high-pressure environments and bring: 

• Structure
• Focus
• Steady energy 

They can triage fast, set priorities, and lead with credibility during crisis or scale. They’re also pragmatic - balancing customer love with commercial reality. 

4. They Build Teams That Stay and Succeed 

Service functions often suffer from high attrition and low engagement. A strong CS Director turns that around. They: 

• Develop clear career paths 
•  Empower team leads 
• Create a high-performance, human-first culture 
• Celebrate wins, own failures, and build real trust 

Their legacy? A team that performs when they’re not in the room. 

5. They Understand the Tech — and the Gaps 

You don’t need a CTO - but your CS Director should know the value (and limits) of: 

• CRMs like Zendesk or Salesforce 
•  Contact centre platforms and telephony 
• AI, chatbots and self-serve tools 
•  Knowledge bases and workflow automation 

They should be able to challenge vendors, champion the right tools, and guide transformation from the front. 

6. They Make Customer Service a Business Driver 

Most importantly, a standout CS Director doesn’t see service as a cost centre. 

They bring: 

• Customer insight into product and marketing 
•  Efficiency into every channel 
• Influence at exec level 
•  Strategic thinking to experience, loyalty and lifetime value 

They’re not managing contact. They’re driving value. 

Final Thought 

Hiring the right Customer Service Director is one of the most important decisions a customer-led business can make. Done right, you’ll get a leader who lifts performance, unlocks loyalty, and future-proofs your customer operation. 

They don’t just run service. They redefine it - and the role it plays in your business.

Looking to hire or shape your next CS Director? 
I help scaling brands scope roles, assess candidates, and build high-performing leadership for customer and commercial success. 

Let’s talk

‍

‍

‍